TV News

"West Wing" creator Aaron Sorkin holds the 2002 Emmy Award for Best Drama Series. Behind him are stars Richard Schiff and John Spencer.
© Michael Caulfield / WireImage.com
"West Wing" creator Aaron Sorkin holds the 2002 Emmy Award for Best Drama Series. Behind him are stars Richard Schiff and John Spencer.
TV's Best: Who's Got Emmy Buzz?
Picking frontrunners and
long shots for this year's awards

By Ray Richmond
The Hollywood Reporter

LOS ANGELES - Sure, NBC political drama "The West Wing" has 22 Primetime Emmy Awards to show for 58 nominations during three seasons of eligibility, including three consecutive outstanding drama series wins. But what has it done for us lately?

While "West Wing" has earned more Emmy statuettes during its first three seasons than has any other TV series during its first three, the winds of buzz seem to be blowing squarely against the show earning a fourth successive top-drama triumph. Perhaps it's inevitable critical backlash against phenomenal success (see David E. Kelley), or maybe it's simply a perception that the show's quality has dropped precipitously of late. Some even blame the political leanings of at least one of "The West Wing's" stars.

"Everyone seems to be turning (against) the show, for whatever reason," says Tom O'Neil, author of the book "The Emmys" and founder of awards-handicapping Web site Goldderby.com. "It's (Fox's) '24' that now has the buzz, the heat, the momentum."

During the next few weeks, contenders will be separated from pretenders as Emmy season kicks into high gear. Nominations for the 55th annual Primetime Emmys will be announced July 17, and the highest-profile statuettes will be handed out Sept. 21 at Los Angeles' Shrine Auditorium during a ceremony set to air on Fox at 8 p.m. ET/PT.

Perception cannot be underestimated at Emmy time. "West Wing" is down; "24" is up. The HBO comedy "Curb Your Enthusiasm" was all the rage when its season ended, but that was months ago. Has it lost that momentum? It is unlikely that the question will keep "Curb" creator/producer/star/Golden Globe winner Larry David up many nights.

Outgoing "West Wing" creator/executive producer Aaron Sorkin isn't terribly worried either.

"The Emmys have been good to us," says Sorkin, who in May wrapped his four-year tenure on the show. "We've been surprised to win every year -- you never expect it, and it never gets old. But in the grand scheme, it doesn't make or break us."

Of course, as anyone armed with a remote and a clue understands too well, the reality-based spectrum has dominated primetime during the past year. CBS' "Survivor" and "The Amazing Race" and Fox's "American Idol" have brought the genre a measure of, well, substance. Still, if Fox's "Joe Millionaire" were somehow to win an Emmy, it could well inspire many folks to leave the country.

The impact of reality-based programming on the scripted-TV world is evident in the dearth of first-year shows that stand much of a chance to land Emmy nominations. Among the few are FX's "Lucky" (eligible in the comedy categories), CBS' "CSI: Miami" and "Without a Trace" and NBC's "Boomtown" and "American Dreams." But even "Dreams" executive producer Jonathan Prince does not much like his show's odds for garnering Emmy attention.

"We're a long shot for a lot of reasons," he says. "We're an 8 o'clock drama on Sunday night, and that works against us. Emmy voters tend to reward the darker hours. If we were on at 10, we'd probably have a much better shot. Being new doesn't help, either."

Reality-based television knows how Prince feels: Respect still tends to come to the genre in dribs from the Academy of Television Arts & Sciences. While ATAS leadership has seen fit to expand nonfiction's representation to four program categories and six individual achievement areas, none of the honors will be handed out during the main Emmy show. Those awards are relegated to the creative arts ceremony, set to take place the previous week.

The following are how some of the bigger races shape up as the Emmys inch toward the starting line.


COMEDY

  • Front-runners: "Curb Your Enthusiasm" (HBO), "Everybody Loves Raymond" (CBS), "Friends" (NBC), "Malcolm in the Middle" (Fox), "Sex and the City" (HBO), "Will & Grace" (NBC)

  • Decent shots: "Frasier" (NBC), "Gilmore Girls" (the WB Network), "The Bernie Mac Show" (Fox), "Monk" (USA Network), "Scrubs" (NBC)

  • Long shots: "Less Than Perfect" (ABC), "Life With Bonnie" (ABC), "George Lopez" (ABC), "Lucky" (FX), "Reba" (the WB), "That '70s Show" (Fox), "Wanda at Large" (Fox)

    Ray RomanoAgain, the drumbeat begins for HBO Independent Prods.' half-hour "Everybody Loves Raymond" to finally bring home the Emmy gold during what is viewed widely as a nadir for TV comedy. Not that "Raymond" has had trouble landing nominations or wins: It earned 11 Emmy mentions last year, 28 during the past three years. Ray Romano snared the lead comedy actor trophy in 2002, when Doris Roberts earned her second supporting comedy actress statuette and Brad Garrett his first supporting comedy actor honor. In addition, Patricia Heaton has won twice (2000 and '01) for lead comedy actress.

    Isn't it about time for "Raymond" to nab the biggest Emmy prize of all?

    "Sure, it would be nice to win, but I don't like how nervous it makes me feel after we get nominated," executive producer Phil Rosenthal says. "I wish we didn't have to sweat out the awards. They should just give everybody a nomination and be done with it because you always have an 80 percent chance of not winning. We never seem to be the 'hot show.'"

    If there is a "show of the moment," it no doubt is "Curb," which last year scored a surprise top-comedy Emmy nom. Then it won a Golden Globe in January for best comedy series, resulting in a memorable acceptance speech from David.

    "Larry sort of feels with these awards that he can't really come out ahead," co-executive producer Bob Weide says. "If he wins, he's embarrassed; if he loses, he's embarrassed. The fact that anyone's even paying attention to us takes him totally by surprise, to be honest."

    There was a groundswell of plaudits last year for "Friends" that led to its first comedy series win (and a statuette for Jennifer Aniston for lead comedy actress). The veteran series is likely to be nominated in the category again, along with "Curb," "Raymond," "Sex" and perhaps "Will."

    But there are at least a handful of other comedies with a rightful claim to nominations, including Regency TV's "Malcolm in the Middle" (shut out in the category last year), sophomores "The Bernie Mac Show" and "Scrubs" and a pair of dramedy hours: the universally praised "Gilmore Girls" and the freshman "Monk."

    Working against "Gilmore" is its berth on the WB, a network dismissed widely as too youth-skewed to appeal to an Emmy majority. Creator/executive producer Amy Sherman-Palladino hopes to pull a "McBeal" by having her show compete again as a comedy, but she knows the battle remains uphill.

    "We're truly a hybrid -- not a pure drama nor a pure comedy -- but if we're one or the other, we're closer to the comedies than the dramas," Sherman-Palladino says. "What we've got on our show are relationships that appeal to viewers of all ages; it would be nice to think that could be rewarded."

    Among comedy performers, "Frasier's" Kelsey Grammer and David Hyde Pierce are in line for their 10th consecutive nominations in the lead and supporting actor categories, respectively. If Grammer makes it to double digits, he is likely to be joined by Romano, David, Frankie Muniz for "Malcolm" (who owns one previous nomination), Eric McCormack of "Will" (a 2001 win on two noms), Bernie Mac and, likely, "Monk's" Tony Shalhoub (a 2003 Globe winner) or Zach Braff for "Scrubs." Supporting actor possibilities also include previous winners Garrett and Sean Hayes ("Will"), "Raymond's" Peter Boyle and John C. McGinley for "Scrubs."

    Among lead comedy actresses, top contenders include Aniston (who also copped a 2003 Globe), Heaton, three-time nominee Jane Kaczmarek for "Malcolm," "Sex's" 2001 outstanding series winner and six-time nominee Sarah Jessica Parker (who is 0-for-4 in the lead actress category) and three-time nominee Debra Messing for "Will." Also hoping to receive attention are "Gilmore" mother Lauren Graham and Bonnie Hunt for "Life With Bonnie." "Friends'" Lisa Kudrow is another possibility, as is Reba McEntire for "Reba."

    The supporting-comedy actress nominee roster should feature Roberts, 2000 winner Megan Mullally for "Will," repeat nominees Kim Cattrall (a 2003 Globe winner) and Cynthia Nixon for "Sex" and, perhaps, "Curb's" Cheryl Hines.


    DRAMA

  • Front-runners: "CSI: Crime Scene Investigation" (CBS), "Law & Order" (NBC), "The Shield" (FX), "Six Feet Under" (HBO), "The Sopranos" (HBO), "24" (Fox), "The West Wing" (NBC)

  • Decent shots: "Alias" (ABC), "Boomtown" (NBC), "CSI: Miami" (CBS), "ER" (NBC), "Judging Amy" (CBS), "The Wire" (HBO)

  • Long shots: "American Dreams" (NBC), "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" (UPN), "Everwood" (the WB), "NYPD Blue" (ABC), "The Practice" (ABC), "Smallville" (the WB), "Without a Trace" (CBS)


    With "The Sopranos" back in the Primetime Emmy race following a one-year hiatus, it is a safe bet that HBO stablemate "Six Feet" will not again land a chart-topping 23 nominations, from which the series earned six statuettes in 2002. Nor will "The West Wing" claim 21 noms, from which it earned four trophies last year. In fact, with Emmy darlings "ER," "Law & Order" and "NYPD Blue" long in the tooth and faced with plenty of high-quality competition, a few new faces could well emerge in the drama categories.

    That said, the outstanding drama series nominees are nearly certain to include the top-rated "CSI," "Sopranos," "Six Feet," "West Wing" and the hot 'n' trendy "24" (a 10-time nominee last year following its first season, for which the series took home a writing statuette). Those are your five nominees, right there.

    If that scenario comes to pass, it would mark the first time in 12 years that "Law" has not appeared on the list. Its 11 consecutive top-drama mentions are an Emmy record and have tied "Law" with comedies "Cheers" and "M*A*S*H" for most consecutive nominations for best series. A mention this year, in other words, would allow "Law" to stand alone among all shows.

    But that distinction probably does not mean much to "Law" creator/executive producer Dick Wolf, right?

    "Like hell, it doesn't," he says. "I hate to be so nakedly needy, but it means everything to all of us associated with this show. We want this nomination desperately. The Emmys are consistently the high point of the year for all of us on 'Law & Order.' I think anyone who's blase about the Emmys shouldn't be nominated."

    That said, with the likely return of "Sopranos" to the race for the top drama prize, "Law" would need to knock out one of last year's other nominees to claim the record -- and that might not happen. In addition, "The Shield" (this year's surprise Globe winner for drama series), critically lauded rookie "Boomtown" and "Alias" (an 11-time nominee last year following its maiden season) also are nipping at the big boys' heels.

    To be sure, though, "Boomtown" creator Graham Yost is not too proud to beg -- or bribe.

    "I'm spending as much money as I can to buy votes," he quips. "You'd be surprised what a couple of fives pressed into the right palms can do for you.

    "Seriously, it's incredibly flattering in our first season just to even hear our name associated with things like Emmys," Yost adds. "I wish I could tell you I have unbridled confidence in it."

    Then there is "CSI" executive producer Anthony Zuiker, who wants an Emmy so badly that he ... well, he goes around touching trophies that belong to other people, "just to see what it looks like and feels like."

    "I'm the biggest awards whore there is," Zuiker admits. "I want to win every award there is -- Genesis, People's Choice, Golden Globe, Emmy, whatever. I've had my Emmy speech prepared for two years; when I finally get to give it, it's going to be the greatest speech of all time. I've got it down to 60 seconds on the dot. But we'll probably be like 'Friends': In Year 9, we'll finally win. I guess I can live with that."

    So competitive has the drama series category become that "The Practice" -- which won the statuette consecutively in 1998 and '99 -- now is given little chance even to land a nomination. Potentially deserving shows such as "Alias," "The Wire," "Judging Amy" and the perennially snubbed "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" (which used to suffer from "the WB syndrome" and now is saddled with "UPN syndrome") also stand to be passed over again.

    With previous "Sopranos" winners James Gandolfini and Edie Falco figuring to return to the lead drama actor and actress categories, respectively, those races are poised to be far less wide-open. Aside from Gandolfini, the lead actor roundup nearly assuredly will include "Shield's" Michael Chiklis, the 2002 Emmy winner (in a major upset) and '03 Globe winner; Kiefer Sutherland for "24"; Martin Sheen for "West Wing"; and Michael C. Hall and Peter Krause, both nominated last year for "Six Feet." "CSI's" William Petersen and "CSI: Miami's" David Caruso also must be considered, as must four-time winner Dennis Franz for "Blue."

    The supporting-drama actor field stands to include the "West Wing" triumvirate of John Spencer, Bradley Whitford and Richard Schiff (all previous Emmy winners, including Spencer last year), Victor Garber for "Alias" and the "Sopranos" trio of Michael Imperioli, Dominic Chianese and Joe Pantoliano. Last year's well-deserved first-time nominees -- "West Wing's" Dule Hill and "Six Feet's" Freddy Rodriguez -- could have a tough time returning for seconds in this crowded category.

    Among lead drama actresses, it all begins with Falco, who already has the 2003 Globe in her pocket for her performance as the long-suffering Carmela Soprano. Falco's competition is likely to include "West Wing's" three-time Emmy winner Allison Janney, who took home last year's statuette following her first lead actress nom; "Alias" queen Jennifer Garner; "Amy's" five-time nominee Amy Brenneman, who is 0-for-3 in the lead actress category; "Six Feet's" Frances Conroy; and "CSI's" Marg Helgenberger.

    For the supporting actress lineup, top possibilities include last year's winner, "West Wing's" Stockard Channing; Channing's castmates Mary-Louise Parker and Janel Moloney, also 2002 nominees; "Six Feet's" Lauren Ambrose and Lili Taylor; Tyne Daly, a five-time Emmy winner who is 0-for-3 in this category as part of the cast of "Amy"; "Shield's" CCH Pounder; and Drea de Matteo for "Sopranos."

    Next: Mini-series and reality-TV Emmys

  • Add a comment
    E-mail
    Digg
    Facebook
    Blog it

    advertisement
    advertisement
    Winter TV Guide
    Today's Staff Picks